The Soda Tax: Robbing Peter to pay Corn Farmers
This past weekend, Peeled Skinny favorite author Mark Bittman published a nice little breakdown of the proposed Soda Tax in the New York Times. He states the important facts, like what's proposed, who's proposed it, and some of the implications. He also expresses how it's part of an over-all movement towards healthier options for kids. Hmmm... and he didn't mention Peeled Snacks?

Obviously this topic resonates with Peeled Snacks. We're trying to offer people better options that your average ju-ju bee chew, and we feel as if we're part of a generation of manufacturers who find the nutrition label to be an important part of their products. I also adore Bittman, and consider his "How to Cook Everything" to be my right-hand-man in the kitchen. But this article, alas, totally misses the point.
All good points within, for sure, but just why is it that Soda is so cheap? Is it because we have some super-cheap food source (say, the "soda plant"?) that grows like a weed? No, it's because we have corn, which is heavily, Heavily, HEAVILY subsidized by the federal government, and we can process the crap out of corn to make corn syrup, which is easily and cheaply added as a sweetener to just about anything and everything.
So what's being proposed here, to protect our kids, is to grow a non-nutritious cash crop, paid for by tax money, have private companies mash it into soda and sell it to kids, and then tax those companies on the sale. This is the very definition of "robbing Peter to pay Paul".
Just because a beverage is carbonated doesn't mean it's part of the problem. A lot of manufacturers out there are trying to contribute SOLUTIONS to the problem, not make it worse (example? FIZZY LIZZY, which Peeled Skinny considers to be ambrosia, no fooling). Yet their fantastic product, which has no sugar added, would be taxed along with the crap-in-a-bottle that some big CPG companies sell.
Granted, the powers that be certainly have the goal of making this tax as easy to manage as possible, so they'd want to lump ANY carbonated beverage (including Fizzy Lizzy) into their little scheme. But hey, you want easy? I've got easy for you:
Eliminate the corn subsidy.
Take away all the money that the federal government pays farmers to grow a crappy crop and use it to pay for whatever this tax was meant to pay for. That's what we around Peeled Snacks world headquarters call a REAL solution to a REAL problem, as opposed to a BOGUS solution to a MADE UP problem. Taxing soda would mean missing the point. And missing the point will keep our kids fat.
Nuff Said,
Peeled Skinny

